Skip links

A Fishy Story for Friday

It’s Lent and suddenly the fast food chains in America are fishing for the Catholic customer.

The convenience food giants learned long ago that on Fridays during Lent Catholics are not buying hamburgers, hot dogs, pork sausages, pastrami, pepperoni, and baloney, barbecue, chops, subs, ribs, steaks and chicken.

In fact it was the Catholics of Cincinnati, Ohio who helped bring about the famous Filet-O-Fish sandwich. In the early 1960s, a McDonald’s franchise owner, Lou Groen recognized that sales dipped badly on Fridays in Lent. Eighty seven percent of his customers were Catholic.

The 1960s were early days for McDonald’s and Groen was struggling to make ends meet. So he cast around for a new idea, and spotted that another restaurant was pulling his missing Catholic customers in selling fish.

So he put some fried fish in a bun, added cheese and tartar sauce and put it on the menu. After a successful trial run he went to headquarters in Chicago and took the idea to McDonald’s founder and CEO Ray Kroc.

Groen recalled the conversation later, “I told Ray Kroc about the idea and he said, ‘You’re always coming up here with a bunch of carp! I don’t want my stores stunk up with the smell of fish!’”

It turned out Kroc had other motives to be pessimistic about the fish sandwich. He was trying to hook people with his own no-meat alternative-the “Hula Burger”-which was a slice of fried pineapple in a bun.

So the next time Lent rolled around, Kroc and Groen had a competition to see which was more popular-the Filet-O-Fish or the Hula Burger. The final score was Filet-O-Fish, three hundred and fifty. Hula Burger six. Customers who tried the Hula Burger said, “I like the Hula, but where’s the burger?”

Read more from Fr. Longenecker. 

Share with Friends: