Federal officials warn states not to defund Planned Parenthood
The legal issues surrounding the defunding of Planned Parenthood will continue to be argued in various legal venues. The importance of the videos is similar to the debate over partial birth abortion: it makes people visualize the brutality inflicted on the weakest among us. The CMP project, in that regard, has already been immensely successful. Here’s another look at the current legal skirmishing. – Al Kresta
Officials in New Hampshire, Alabama, and Louisiana have announced plans to defund Planned Parenthood in the wake of a series of undercover videos from a pro-life group.
But cutting that funding may violate federal law, reports The Wall Street Journal, since Medicaid beneficiaries can received services from “any qualified provider.”
That includes Planned Parenthood, according to federal officials, who have warned states against cutting funds to the billion-dollar nonprofit.
The warning comes as the Center for Medical Progress (CMP) released its sixth video targeting Planned Parenthood. The video is the sixth in a series of twelve that the pro-life group plans to release.
In the latest video, a former tissue procurement technician says she was told to acquire fetal tissue without consent at a Planned Parenthood clinic in California.
Holly O’Donnell claims her former supervisors at StemExpressLLC told her that getting tissue donations was a demand and not an option. Federal law requires that a woman having an abortion give consent for donating tissue.
“If there was a higher gestation, and the technicians needed it, there were times when they would just take what they wanted,” O’Donnell said in the video. “And these mothers don’t know. And there’s no way they would know.”
A review of all 12 hours of unedited CMP video shows Planned Parenthood acting in an ethically questionable manner, says Vox.com writer Sarah Kliff.
“The videos are edited to make Planned Parenthood look bad,” she wrote. “But that doesn’t mean Planned Parenthood didn’t do anything wrong.”
Columnist Ruben Navarrett agrees.
In the past, Navarrett has described himself as pro-choice. The videos, he wrote in the Daily Beast, have made him question that position.
“It’s jarring to see doctors acting as negotiators as they dicker over the price of a fetal liver, heart, or brain, and then talk about how they meticulously go to the trouble of not crushing the most valuable body parts,” he wrote. “This practice is perfectly legal, and for some people, it is just a business. With millions of abortions each year in America, business is good.”
Federal law allows Planned Parenthood to be reimbursed for costs involved in acquiring donation tissue. Previous CMP videos have focused on Planned Parenthood officials haggling over the price for fetal tissue over lunch and at adissection table. Another shows a Planned Parenthood official claiming that staff can alter abortion techniques to obtain intact fetuses for donation.
David Daleiden, executive director of the CMP, argues that Planned Parenthood’s tissue donation is immoral and illegal.
“So Planned Parent does nothing, yet they still are receiving $50, $75, or $100 per specimen,” he told CT in an interview earlier this summer. “So they are clearly selling fetal tissue for valuable consideration and for a profit—and that is very clearly against the law.”
Daleiden supports efforts to cut government funding for Planned Parenthood. Federal funding remains the largest single revenue source for the nation’s largest abortion provider, according to The Washington Post.
The Post and other news outlets recently examined competing claims about Planned Parenthood’s funding and service.
Planned Parenthood claims that only 3 percent of its services are abortion-related. A story by Rachael Larimore, a writer for Slate.com, labeled that claim as “the most meaningless abortion statistic ever.” Most women who have abortions at Planned Parenthood also have other related services at the same time.
Overall, Larimore pointed out, about a third of Planned Parenthood’s income comes from abortion.
Americans remain divided over the issue of abortion. Earlier this year, a Gallup pollfound that half (50 percent) describe themselves as pro-choice. Forty-four percent say they are pro-life.
A survey of registered voters, sponsored by Planned Parenthood, found that about two-thirds (63 percent) of those voters opposed calls to defund Planned Parenthood.
